by Robin Garr » Thu Apr 23, 2009 5:13 pm
I wasn't blown away by it in my Aug. 9, 2007 review of Amerigo. The topping, a blend of local cheeses, made good use of good ingredients, but the wood-oven effect didn't really come through for me:
I chose the “Kentuckiana cheese” wood-fired pizza ($10), billed as a blend of “local” blue, goat and white cheddar cheeses with basil walnut pesto. I assume the cheeses came from Capriole Farm in Indiana and Kenny Mattingly in Kentucky; I wish management had thought to promote the local vendors on the menu. The pizza was oval, not round, the shape of a flattened football. The thin honey-yeast crust wasn’t particularly inspiring, perhaps yanked out of the wood oven a little too soon; but the “white” all-cheese pie with its combination of mild, earthy and tangy cheeses made an appealing alternative to the usual tomato-sauce pizza.