JThompson wrote:I apologize, but if I can make one more point. Some people may disagree with my POV. Chef's have been using Escoffier, Point, Bocuse, etc, etc. as inspiration. How many Chef's have met these masters? An Inspiration is whatever it may be. Chef Richards played a large part in keeping me in school and realizing my dream. I have only been good at three things and food is one of them.
Perhaps I missed what you were trying to do. If so, I apologize.
The way your original post read, seemed (at least to me) that you wondered what some dishes other people had experienced and loved at Zephyr Cove, and were looking to draw inspiration from them.
The "gray area" I referenced was comparable to the "telephone game" - you take the descriptions people give you of dishes they had years ago, that may be foggy in recollection, you never saw how it was presented, tasted how it was prepared, nor have the original menu description, etc... and a little gets lost in translation.
I am all for tributes and homages in dishes... but do it by things that have inspired you personally.
Personally I've done a number of desserts that are a riff on one singular dish and it's theme.
The menu description read "inspired by Gale Gand"... but the only inspiration was from the three central flavor components. From there, I put my own spin on things, etc. and it hardly resembled the original dish. And no - I hadn't had the dish at the time (I since have had a variation of it at TRU last year - a very deliberate "quest" to put things in perspective).
My point though is this... it was my interpretation of something that particularly inspired me.
I didn't deliberately go fishing for a dish by another pastry chef to pay tribute... nor did I say "Gale Gand has really inspired me... i should do a riff on one of her desserts." It was only after I had conceptualized the entire dish, did i make the realization that the key flavor profiles were inspired by something i saw in a book - but the inspiration was subconscious.
Tributes and homages are something that come entirely from the heart and should come without thinking.
On the notion of wanting to pay tribute to one of your mentors... by all means, do it!
But do it from your heart, from something that directly inspires you.
It doesn't even have to be direct or obvious to anyone but you.
The more the homage comes from the deepest parts of your soul (and less from asking other people what they remember), it bears more reverence and it's more rooted in your affection for there mentorship - not what other people liked about them.
If you really want to get down to the bare bones of it... most modern (western) cookery is inspired (directly/indirectly or otherwise) by the old French masters anyway. Any tribute food-wise should be focused, otherwise every single last one of us (cooks) would have a laundry list for each dish of who inspired who, yada yada yada... back for 100 years. Sort of like a genealogy/family tree for every dish. Know what I mean?