As someone who lives in Madison, it's been hard watching some of the better restaurants vanish in the last few years, like Ovo Cafe, McQuiston's Malthouse, even the Local Harvest Market, which had wonderful prepared foods.
If you'd rather eat in 2008 than 1965, go to the
Red Pepper Deli and Cafe. The sandwiches are great, and now, they're doing dinner on Friday and Saturday nights, with a new menu each weekend. Usually, they're doing steak, salmon, that kind of thing. As their site says, "it's not just for lunch anymore." My wife's current favorite is the cajun shrimp and andouille sausage over pasta, which is heavenly. It's easily the best restaurant in town these days. Knowing the level of foodies on this forum, it's also the only place I'd recommend whole-heartedly.
There's also Bistro One, which has more of Greek and Mediterranean flavor, but their hours are pretty random. (In eight years, we've tried to go there several times. We've only successfully eaten there once.)
Hinkle's is fine if you're in the mood for the White Castle style of food, just not made by a chain restaurant.
If you want to dine with a good river view, bring a picnic or eat from the vendors at the Folk Festival. Or get takeout from Red Pepper.
_________________________
David J. Loehr
Riverrun Theatre Companythe professional theatre of Madison, Indiana