John NA wrote:I've been there. I've been to better places but I've also been to far worse places. Her experience did not match my experience at all. Our food was good and we had great service. I plan to go back.
Marsha L. wrote:I'm so sorry to say, the one time we went there it smelled awful in the dining room, so awful that we only ordered drinks from the cook who came from the back of the house to be our server. We went across the street for pizza at Clifton's. I really wanted to like it, too.
SilvioM wrote:I don't get the one-star comment. She had several positive things to say (pesto, meat sauce, escargot, A+ service) and things that she didn't like. Mixed, hence the 2.5. I've only been once, was fine but not memorable, so I can't comment about the place much myself, but I don't think the review was, based on one experience, off by that much.
Robin Garr wrote:There's the issue of her accuracy, and there is the issue of her tone and style. I agree that she said some kind things, and I agree that some of her criticism may be justified.
Marsha....if you were "across the street" from Clifton's, no WONDER "it smelled awful".....you were dining at River City Tire Co.!Marsha L. wrote:I'm so sorry to say, the one time we went there it smelled awful in the dining room, so awful that we only ordered drinks from the cook who came from the back of the house to be our server. We went across the street for pizza at Clifton's. I really wanted to like it, too.
Foodie
761
Fri Jun 20, 2008 9:43 pm
Camp Taylor aka Louisville's food desert
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 42 guests