David Clancy
Foodie
730
Thu Mar 01, 2007 12:09 pm
A couch in Andy's house.
Hmmm...agree with most of this as well as Dan's response...but, I was taken aback by the "cult of CIA" comment. I have never been to culinary school (got a degree but it's been as helpfull as a tumor in this business) and have worked my way up from dish (class of 1978) but every CIA grad I have encountered over the years has had REAL chops, Unlike CCA/ Sullivan et al.Jayson L wrote:a kitchen stage ( pr:staj ) is a vital part of building a fundamental understanding of working in a pro kitchen. It’s also pivotal in creating relationships and networks inside the industry for future employment. Something a lot of people don’t understand - great chefs are built by their industry experience and relationships during the "climb up the latter." Well known establishments, rooted in uber quality and discipline very seldom resort to the "resume" process in finding a new Chef. It’s a tight little network inside the industry, and most of us keep in touch with each other from coast to coast. In order to access the group - in line with what Chef Ryan was saying - you have to pay your dues. It has very little to do with your culinary education - that is unless you belong to the CIA cult. (they seem to have created an exclusivity sect in our industry that is comical to say the least)
As for getting your foot in the door - I will recommend two things. You aren’t going to get yourself into a disciplined kitchen having zero experience. Even working for free, no one in that environment has time to teach you how to set up a prep station not to mention walk behind you and fix everything. Harsh reality maybe - but all things worth earning are worth working hard for. So be smart and realistic about what you are trying to achieve. Second: start with a place that you can at least get yourself into a working understanding of the core idea of pro cooking. Learn how to work under the stress, work clean and organized, understand the politics of the kitchen, and then some basic knife and cooking skills. Bring to your first Stage something for the chef to work with -if he’s worth his weight - he'll take care of the rest....welcome to the club
David Clancy
Foodie
730
Thu Mar 01, 2007 12:09 pm
A couch in Andy's house.
Agreed.....Just measuring quality of "formal" education, I'd take a dude with a year in the trenches over anyone with a culinary degree every time!Jayson L wrote:Dave. You are right though - CIA does breed fundamentalism. or... sorry - you said fundamentals - I catch what you are saying now. haha... you were joking around right? CIA is a common punch line in a lot of kitchens - just a little inside joking and rivalry...nothing big... I think the entire idea of "Culinary Arts" programs is a bit more gauged to make prospective students think they are gaining an upper hand over their counterparts working up the ranks sans Culinary Arts Programs. The programs should be more marketed to people with an established skill set before entering the program as a way to hone an already established skillset. Without the practical understanding of what it is you are trying to achieve, I’m not sure how you can really understand how to make the skill sharper. Make sense? Most domestic culinary curriculums only have the students working in 45% total lab (hands on actual cooking) That’s ridiculous...My opinion - if you really want to build a true fundamental base of the classics, either work in a kitchen rooted in classic discipline or go international.
David Clancy wrote:I'd take a dude with a year in the trenches over anyone with a culinary degree every time!
Users browsing this forum: Claudebot, Facebook and 4 guests