by Brad Keeton » Fri Apr 15, 2011 11:19 am
We went last night and were quite pleased. The decor is sleek and contemporary, and certainly not that of your typical "pizza joint." We shared the arancini, wedge salad, and Brownsboro pizza, and for simplicity I'll just echo what everyone else has posted - they were all excellent. Coal's pizza rivals Papalino's and a few of the Boombozz special pizzas as our favorites. Service from Aaron was attentive and friendly.
I only have two small nits. First, and along the lines of what Gary posted above, our pizza could have used another minute or so in the oven. The outside 3/4 of the crust was perfect, but the inside 1/4 was just a little underdone. When you picked it up, the end drooped just a little and the toppings slid off. Still, it was an outstanding pizza, and I'm sure cooking pizza in that much heat can be a guessing game sometimes.
Second, the bourbon selection could use a little work and please, never, ever, list Jack Daniels on your list of bourbons. Jack Daniels is Tennessee sour mash whiskey, never to be mentioned in the same breath as good Kentucky bourbon.
Otherwise, we loved it, and will be back often. My wife said "I could see us here every Thursday."
"I don't eat vegans. They're too bony."
-Alton Brown